Alan Zendell, April 13, 2026
When Donald Trump is in thrall of being Commander-in-Chief of the world’s most powerful military, his bombastic style consists in equal parts of lies, exaggerations, and delusional fantasies. What it never contains is an admission of any possibility of being wrong, any suggestion of contrition, and worst of all, any evidence of rational, competent planning.
The forty-day war has wasted the lives of thirteen American service members and more than 3,000 people in Iran, Lebanon, and Israel, most of whom were civilians. Trump’s war has not only not achieved its primary objectives, but if the Iranians accept JD Vance’s “best and final offer” they will be in a much stronger position than they were before Trump tore up the nuclear agreement the Obama administration and the EU negotiated. Most objective observers believe that that agreement was working, and Trump’s decision to end it was pure personal animus toward Obama.
Both Trump and Israeli PM Benjamin Netanyahu promised their populations that attacking Iran by air would end both its nuclear enrichment program and the tyrannical Iranian regime, and destroy Iran’s missiles and drones. Netanyahu had tried to sell this narrative to three previous American presidents, but Geroge W. Bush, Barrack Obama, and Joe Biden all rejected it. Two center-left presidents and one who learned from experience that military incursions in the Middle East are like slogging through quicksand all understood that Netanyahu’s plan was a Hail Mary that had little or no chance of success. Yet, Trump fell for Netanyahu’s seductive appeal to his ego, because that’s what Trump lives for.
Netanyahu has been desperately trying to avoid a felony trial for corruption – in Israel, the PM does not have a get-out-of-jail-free card, compliments of its Supreme Court – and Trump has been dealing with the repercussions of his failed tariff and immigration policies and the specter of the Epstein Files. War against Iran suited both their personal agendas. To be fair to Netanyahu, his country has been at war for the entire seventy-eight years of its existence, surrounded by neighbors sworn to destroy it. From his point of view, even a Hail Mary was better than the status quo.
On the other hand, rational actors knew the attack on Iran would never succeed. Iran is not Venezuela, Cuba, Greenland, Grenada, or Panama, and the geography of the Persian Gulf gives Iran an advantage that cannot be overcome with air power. Eliminating Iran’s enriched uranium, which Netanyahu and Trump both claimed was their primary objective, was something Israeli and American military leaders knew from the start was not achievable with air strikes alone. Netanyahu knew it, too, but when Trump’s ego is in charge, rational thought takes a back seat.
How do we know the attack plan was doomed to fail? My own personal experience and that of many thousands of American military and civilians prove it. Iran isn’t the only country that buries it’s vital assets deep underground. I worked in one such facility during the Vietnam War, a fully functional military complex at Raven Rock Mountain, buried under eight-thousand feet of granite in Pennsylvania, It was built in the 1950s to provide a secure location from which the Joint Chiefs of Staff could retaliate in the event of a nuclear attack by the Soviet Union. Only a direct hit by a hydrogen bomb could affect it or similar facitilities like Cheyenne Mountain in Colorado.
It’s an absolute certainty that both Netanyahu and Trump were aware that the same thing is true of the underground site at Istafan where the enriched uranium is kept. Unless they planned to use nuclear weapons, extracting the cannisters of uranium would require an extended ground war, neither of which were on Trump’s radar.
A poll by The Econmist last week asked responders who was winning the war. 2% said the U. S., 6% said Israel, 17% said Iran, and everyone else said None of the Above, and reputable polls in both Israel in the United States taken since Trump’s cease fire was declared found that nearly three quarters of Israelis and Americans consider the war a failure and believe Iran may now be a worse threat than before the bombing started.
The promises of regime change were equally disingenuous, and both Trump and Netanyahu understood that before the war started. Killing nearly a hundred of Iran’s top pollitical leaders did not “cut off the head of the snake.” Iran’s Revolutionary Guard and its religious autocracy number more than a million well-entrenched fanatical Shia Muslims who hate everything in the Judeo-Christian world and whose twisted version of Islam lists killing Jews, Americans, and Europeans as a pathway to Heaven.
We’ve been lied to. We have allowed our unstable, delusional president to drag us into a war from which there is no productive exit. Given the extremely negative response by both Americans and Israelis to the prospect of a full-scale war, and Iran’s ability and willingness to absorb destruction and use it to reinforce it’s people’s anger and hatred, it’s impossible to see this war as anything but an incompetent failure.